Skip to content
Geese Magazine
Search

Nov 20, 2026

Mamdani is Socialism

America has finally begun to embrace socialism–in the face of New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani.

by Mitch Abidor

"Socialism, to me, means that you will have whatever you need to live a dignified life and that it is the government's job to deliver on that."

Zohran Mamdani


Discussions about the rising popularity of socialism in the US are essentially meaningless. What is the socialism that 40% of Americans say they prefer to capitalism? Is it worker control of the means of production after the expropriation of the expropriators? The establishment of the dictatorship of the proletariat? Or is it more likely, as George Orwell proposed in The Road to Wigan Pier, that “to the ordinary working man … socialism does not mean much more than better wages and shorter hours and nobody bossing you about.” A socialist society would be a more just society (Orwell again:: Socialism means  justice and common decency”), but a more just society would not necessarily be a socialist one. And even if 40% of Americans – most of them young – prefer some sort of socialism, a socialism that hasn’t been defined, almost 60% don’t.

There is more. As Susan Neiman has pointed out in Call it Evil, her book on evil in the time of Trump, the foundation of any socialism, even in its mildest forms, where capitalism and socialism coexist within the same society, as in the much-vaunted Scandinavian countries, requires a mentality that accepts, even demands its social rights. The belief that we have a right to housing, to health care, to education, to food, to childcare, not as favors granted, but as our rights as humans who want to live decently, is far from being accepted, or even acceptable to many Americans. These rights are viewed as both unrealizable and unamerican. The cult of individual responsibility is the true enemy of the social.

A belief in socialism requires a belief in the state that will manage it. The hatred of the government and the belief it exists only to pick our pockets is its corollary and solidifies the opposition to socialism. The Reaganite claim that government is not the solution to our problems, but is the problem, is too well-anchored in political life. The road to socialism in any form is long, for it has barely begun.

The notion that we will progress from capitalism to socialism and then on to communism omits some key steps. Within the capitalism of today, in order for people to even consider socialism, they must advance two large steps that have been insufficiently addressed: they must recognize they have social rights and must demand them, and once they are obtained, they must have a state they believe will deliver them.  

This is radically unlike European nations, almost all of which have a reliable social safety net that recognizes some of these social rights. The regular explosions of rage in France have their root in the feeling that the social rights people feel they have are being infringed upon, taken from them, or ignored. Once upon a time they had rights and the government didn’t try to take them away. They still feel they have rights, but no longer believe in a state that will protect and maintain the rights. This is ultimately a step backwards that drives the socialist option even further away in a country like France, with a strong socialist tradition.

Any discussion of socialism in the US then has to begin at point zero. In fact, at less than zero. And this is where Zohran Mamdani enters.

Zohran is the face of socialism in America. This is simply undeniable. His name comes up in conversations all over the country, but not only here. Slavoj Zizek recently discussed him on the BBC; on a trip late last year to France almost every conversation turned to Zohran when I told people I was from New York. He has become a byword for progressive municipal politics.

Zohran’s three main proposals while running for mayor were freezing rents, free buses, and free child care for all. Though these are certainly demands a socialist can support, there is nothing specifically socialist about them. Though the impeccably revolutionary Paris Commune addressed the matter of rent with several measures, including cancelling all debts for unpaid sums due, rents were frozen under the non-socialist Bill di Blasio; child care is free in non-socialist locales around the world; free buses are rare, but it can be implemented anywhere at any time by any mayor or governor.  

These programs do nothing to overturn property relations or the capitalist system. What they do do, and which in the current juncture is far more important, is propose to the public a vision of government action at odds to what they are used to, and which thoroughly challenges today’s widespread cynicism. 

No socialist program can succeed or even be listened to if it is presented as a purely theoretical plan. Precisely what makes Mamdani’s program insufficient to some on the left is what makes it the right one. He is not addressing an idealized working class but real people where they really are. He recognizes that it is only when people recognize that a program capable of benefiting them and meeting immediate needs can be successfully implemented that they will be ready to listen to the more distant and truly socialist goals.

While some in Geese have criticized Mamdani for not taking more of a confrontational stance, Mamdani’s avoidance of upsetting the order of things actually figures as a strength. As the Supreme Court demonstrated during FDR’s New Deal, even a mild upsetting of things can and will be declared illegal. The 1935 Shechter decision should be forever before our eyes, for the reactionary Supreme Court of today would be every bit as quick as its predecessor to shut down any measure intended to change or regulate property relations. The recent delay in the implementation of the pied-a-terre tax by a local New York judge is there to remind us of this.

This is the genius of Mamdani’s main proposals, as well as his proposed city run supermarkets and a rise in taxes on the wealthy: they are court proof. No law demands fares be paid on buses; no laws require child care to be expensive; and the law allows for rents to be frozen. His choice of issues is impeccable on all levels. They are popular and they are legal. They push the boundaries of what is acceptable without inviting suppression and defeat.

Mamdani’s founding of the Department of Mass Engagement is also a noteworthy event. It is not necessarily socialist (a good example of a precursor is, after all, Huey Long’s Every Man a King Clubs), but, as those who have participated in it can attest, it shows New Yorkers that Mamdani’s plans require and enable the city government to show it was still there for them even after winning office–that the state welcomes and even demands popular participation and mobilization.

Given all this, given the potential Mamdani’s non-socialist proposals have to open minds to the possibility of true socialist measures by showing they have social rights and that government can be a source of good–his every success is ours. So, too, is every failure. The role of socialists and even those who call themselves communists is the unstinting and active support of Mamdani.

Every will should be bent to ensuring and explaining his program. This also requires socialists recognizing that Mamdani is governing under capitalism and all that implies. His program requires the spending of public moneys. Public moneys mean taxes, which require a tax base. Destroying that will mean the definite failure of the benefits of a mayor like Zohran. He clearly recognizes this, and this leads to measures leftists might not be enthusiastic about.

Sometimes, you just have to focus on what matters right now. This is that time.

The Paris Commune will not be reproduced in the US, or anywhere else for that matter. Those who think the grand soir will come because it has to come are abdicating their responsibility. Knocking on doors to encourage people to join tenant unions in the name of Mamdani is our equivalent to building a barricade. Mass engagement is our pamphleteering. Successful governance is the most effective and iron form of agitation.

In the American context, in terms of his social role, Mamdani is our Blanqui, our Bordiga, our Pannekoek. It’s not that much is riding on Zohran; it’s that everything is.